Colgate-Palmolive has agreed to pay $2.9 million to settle claims that its Tom’s of Maine toothpaste was manufactured under conditions that allegedly violated federal quality standards. The deadline to submit a claim passed on July 6, 2026.
While Colgate-Palmolive maintains it did nothing wrong, it agreed to the settlement to avoid the cost and uncertainty of a trial.
Who qualifies
You qualified for this settlement if you bought one or more Tom’s of Maine toothpaste products in the United States between November 21, 2020, and March 6, 2026, for personal use rather than resale.
The class covered Tom’s of Maine toothpaste sold nationwide through third-party retailers during that window, no matter which state you live in. If you bought the product for a business, to resell, or for some other commercial purpose, you weren’t part of the class.
Anyone who opted out of the class by the deadline is excluded from this settlement and could not file a claim.
Claim filing has closed
The window to file a claim in this settlement has closed on July 6, 2026. Claims are no longer being accepted — see the payment timeline below for what happens next.
Claim deadline
The deadline to file a claim was on July 6, 2026. The filing period is now closed.
What the settlement covers
Colgate-Palmolive’s Tom’s of Maine subsidiary agreed to a $2.9 million fund to resolve lawsuits accusing the company of selling toothpaste made under manufacturing conditions that fell short of federal standards.
The dispute traces back to a May 2024 FDA inspection of Tom’s manufacturing facility in Sanford, Maine, which found conditions that did not comply with the FDA’s Current Good Manufacturing Practices.
After the inspection, the company reviewed pre-release testing data covering roughly 4,900 finished toothpaste batches made over a three-year period and reported that none of the batches posed a safety risk to consumers. Multiple lawsuits followed, alleging deceptive and misleading practices in how Tom’s of Maine products were manufactured, marketed, and sold.
Those cases were consolidated before Judge James M. Wicks in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, and the resulting fund covers Class memberSomeone who falls within the court-approved class definition and is eligible to receive settlement benefits (unless they opt out).Learn more about Class member claims, notice and administrative costs, service awards, and attorneys’ fees.
How much you could get
How it compares
Smaller than 51% of the consumer protection settlements we track, tied for 23rd smallest of 48.
This settlement $2.9 million
Smallest$400,000
Median$2.95 million
Largest$700 million
As of . Our own records of open and closed settlements, not a complete history.
How much each filer receives depends on which claim type they chose and how many valid claims were submitted against the settlement fund.
- Without Proof of purchaseDocuments showing you bought or used the covered product/service (receipts, invoices, statements, order confirmations, etc.).Learn more about Proof of purchase: the average manufacturer’s suggested retail price for up to one Tom’s of Maine product per household.
- With proof of purchase: a full refund of the amount spent on Class Products, capped at three products per household.
Proof of purchase, where provided, could include documentation such as an itemized receipt or loyalty card record showing the purchase price, date, place, and number of units bought. If total valid claims exceed what the fund can cover, individual payments may be reduced on a pro rata basis.
No payments have gone out yet. The settlement has not received final court approval, and money moves only after that happens and any appeal period passes.
The allegations
The lawsuit alleges that Colgate-Palmolive and its Tom’s of Maine subsidiary manufactured toothpaste under conditions that fell short of federal quality requirements, and that the companies sold those products without disclosing the issues found during the FDA’s May 2024 inspection.
Plaintiffs argued that this amounted to deceptive and misleading business practices in how the toothpaste was made, labeled, and sold.
Colgate-Palmolive and Tom’s of Maine deny all allegations of wrongdoing and deny any liability. The court has not determined that either company did anything wrong, and the companies agreed to the settlement, filed as Case No. 2:25-cv-6996 (JMW), to avoid the cost and uncertainty of continued litigation.











